While the Star Wars series is accustomed to igniting the screen with lightsaber duels, Andor takes a bold step back - throughout its entire 12-episode run, not a single lightsaber is drawn. This narrative choice to "de-lightsaberize" is not a departure from the classic, but rather uses a more realistic brushstroke to reveal the most essential nature of the resistance movement. The following is a deep exploration of this "swordless battle" from three dimensions.
1. The narrative strategy of the absence of lightsabers: restoring the authenticity of "ordinary people's resistance"
Star Wars has always been building its story background through the light side and the dark side. Andor presents the normal life from the perspective of ordinary people, allowing us to have a deeper understanding of the underlying logic of Star Wars and making the Star Wars universe more vivid and realistic.
Image from: star wars.com
1.1 Deconstructing the "Force Myth": The Subject of Resistance is the Ordinary Person
In traditional Star Wars stories, lightsabers and the Force form the core framework of the hero's narrative: Jedi Knights use lightsabers as a medium and the Force to turn the tide of battle. But Andor focuses its lens on Felix's miners, the low-level workers on Coruscant, and the crew members on smuggling ships - these ordinary people without Force talents are the flesh and blood of the Rebel Alliance.
In the grand narrative of "Star Wars", the Jedi Knights were once the military backbone of the Galactic Republic, the most elite "military force". However, after Palpatine seized control of the Galactic Republic, the Jedi Order disintegrated. Without an organization, they were like kites without strings - Obi-Wan chose to bury his lightsaber, hide his identity on Tatooine, and become an ordinary person. There were many Jedi like him.
After the Sith took control of the galaxy, a series of works emerged: "Obi-Wan", "Ahsoka", "The Mandalorian", "The Book of Boba Fett", and an animated series centered around the Clone Wars. Together, they depict a corner of the Star Wars universe. However, these works share a common feature - they focus on the revolutionary struggle led by the Jedi.
And "Andor" stands out uniquely. It breaks away from the conventional "Jedi perspective" framework and delves into the perspective of ordinary people, allowing us to witness how ordinary individuals are swept up by the times and struggle and make choices amid the turmoil of the galaxy. It fills the gap of the "commoner perspective" in the narrative of "Star Wars", making the stories of the entire Star Wars universe more three-dimensional and relatable through the joys and sorrows of these "ordinary people".
Image from: star wars.com
In episode three, after Andor shot an Imperial soldier to save his sister, his trembling hands and the blood-stained wrench formed a stark contrast. This "non-heroic" violent scene completely overturned the romanticized imagination of lightsaber duels.
1.2 Reconstruct the weight of resistance with "daily details"
The "energy beam" feature of the lightsaber comes with a sci-fi filter by default, while "Andor" opts to use mundane elements such as "screws", "data disks", and "worn-out spaceships" to carry the mission of resistance.
Image from: star wars.com
In the Star Wars series, the "energy beam" feature of lightsabers is undoubtedly a highly iconic sci-fi element. The blade of a lightsaber glows with brilliant light, and when wielded in battle, it emits a distinctive hum, slices through the air, and collides with other lightsabers to produce intense sparks and release dazzling energy. This energy beam feature not only provides a strong visual impact on the audience but also, from a setting perspective, reflects the mystery and power of the Force, becoming a symbol of the identity and strength of Jedi Knights and Sith Lords. It endows the entire Star Wars series with a thick sci-fi atmosphere and fantasy color, and has become an important representative of the sci-fi charm of Star Wars in the hearts of the audience, making them full of imagination about the battles and adventures in distant galaxies.
However, "Andor" takes a different approach. It opts to use seemingly mundane elements such as "screws", "data disks", and "worn-out spaceships" to carry the mission of resistance. The "screw" represents the most basic and unremarkable industrial part. In "Andor", it symbolizes every ordinary person who quietly contributes to the resistance organization. They may not have powerful Force or be able to wield lightsabers, but they perform their duties meticulously in their respective positions, like screws, to resist the rule of the Empire, for freedom and justice, and support the entire resistance movement.
The "data disk" serves as the carrier of information and wisdom. In the drama, it stores crucial intelligence that determines the success or failure of the resistance movement, such as the Empire's military deployment and secret plans. The resistance fighters have to risk their lives to obtain, transfer and interpret the information on these data disks. Every action related to the data disks is full of tension and excitement. It reflects the technological confrontation between the resistance organization and the Empire, as well as how they use wisdom and strategy to fight against the powerful enemy, demonstrating the complexity and difficulty behind the resistance mission.
The "old and dilapidated spaceships" are even more representative. Compared with the brand-new, advanced and imposing warships of the Empire, the spaceships of the resistance organization look shabby and worn out. But it is precisely these seemingly backward and dilapidated spaceships that carry the hopes and dreams of the rebels. They shuttle through the universe, undertaking dangerous missions. Although they may break down at any time due to aging equipment and other issues, the rebels, relying on their belief in freedom and superb piloting skills, complete the impossible tasks time and again. The old and dilapidated spaceships symbolize the rebels' unyielding spirit in the face of scarce resources and a huge disparity in strength. They bravely challenge the Empire with their tenacious will and pursuit of justice, allowing the audience to see the arduousness of the resistance mission and the perseverance of the rebels.
Image from: star wars.com
Through these ordinary elements, "Andor" breaks the previous model of the "Star Wars" series, which overly relied on supernatural forces and cool sci-fi equipment to drive the story. It presents the complexity and authenticity of the resistance movement from a more realistic and down-to-earth perspective, allowing the audience to better feel the great power of ordinary people fighting for their ideals in the historical tide.
In the fifth episode, the rebels passed on intelligence by embroidering codes on towels in the laundry room. This kind of "secret in daily life" is closer to the wisdom of real resistance movements than lightsabers.
2. The Narrative Ambition of De-Saberizing: Redefining "Star Wars-style Rebellion"
In the Star Wars universe, the setting of lightsabers and the Force builds the narrative foundation of the "heroic talent theory" - only those chosen by the Force and capable of wielding lightsabers, the Jedi Knights, are the core force resisting tyranny in the galaxy, as if ordinary people are destined to be mere onlookers of history. But Andor completely breaks this narrative pattern: there are no dazzling lightsaber duels, no chosen ones with the ability to control the Force. Every rebel is an ordinary person oppressed by the Empire - Cassian from the lower class, Luthen, a wealthy merchant who has lost everything, and even a prisoner struggling to survive in prison. They choose to resist not because of bloodlines or superpowers, but simply because after witnessing the atrocities of the Empire, they made the most simple human choice between "submitting to enslavement" and "rising up in resistance".
2.1 The essence of rebellion is "choice" rather than "innate ability".
"Andor" replaces lightsabers and the Force with "screws", "rusted spaceships" and "encrypted data disks", revealing a more realistic truth: the essence of resistance has never been the exclusive privilege of a few with special talents, but rather the active choice of all when facing oppression. When ordinary people pick up simple weapons, use their wisdom to crack imperial secrets, and protect the flame of freedom with their lives, they prove that true heroism stems from the courage of ordinary individuals to say "no" to injustice in the darkest moments.
Mortima transformed from a rich girl into an organizer of an intelligence network. Her "weapons" were connections and courage, rather than lightsabers.
In the first episode, Cassian merely aimed to save his sister, but through a series of choices, he became a symbol of resistance. This "ordinary person's growth arc" broke the deterministic view of lightsaber-wielding heroes.
2.2 Replace "personal legend" with "collective narrative."
While traditional Star Wars films focus on core characters like the Skywalker family, Andor uses ensemble performances to showcase the complexity of the rebellion.
Take the tenth episode as an example. The episode unfolds three distinct storylines through a sophisticated multi-threaded narrative: in the underground printing press on Coruscant, the rebels spread the truth with ink and paper; on an alien colony, laborers fight against the oppression of the Empire with their bare hands; in the meeting room of the rebel high command, strategists carefully weigh every move. These scenes lack the flash of lightsabers and the roar of the Force, yet they more authentically depict the complexity of the rebellion than any heroic epic – it is the cautiousness of the printers taking risks, the courage of the laborers' cries, and the heavy responsibility of the decision-makers.
Image from: star wars.com
"Andor" uses this ensemble narrative to prove that the collapse of the Galactic Empire was not the achievement of any single hero, but the result of the continuous resistance of countless ordinary people in different times and spaces, in different ways. Every intelligence liaison, every technician who sabotaged facilities, every idealist who held fast to their beliefs, were all indispensable pieces of this resistance movement. When these "ordinary people's sparks" crossed galaxies and converged, they were enough to illuminate the entire dark universe.
Image from: star wars.com
3. The Guidance of the Force VS The Awakening of the Common People
In the traditional Star Wars universe, the Force is portrayed as a nearly all-knowing and all-powerful supernatural entity:
Divine prophecy and guidance: Jedi Masters can "foresee" crises through the Force (such as Yoda sensing the rise of the Empire), Anakin predicted his mother's death with the Force, and Palpatine tempted Anakin to the dark side by claiming that the "Dark Side of the Force can bring back the dead" - the Force becomes the "hand of God" that controls destiny, and individual choices are incorporated into a preordained narrative track.
3.1 The Force Myth: The "Supernatural Omnipotence Theory" Exaggerated to the Extreme
The subversion of physical laws: from Luke using the Force to control objects and destroy the Death Star, to Rey using the Force to resurrect Kylo Ren, the enhanced slashes with the Force during lightsaber duels can even cut through the armor of starships. These settings have elevated the Force to the status of an "omnipotent magic", and even made the ability to "bring the dead back to life", which defies the laws of nature, a "bargaining chip" of the dark side.
Monopoly on battlefield dominance: The core battlefields against the Sith have always been dominated by the Jedi Knights - in "Revenge of the Sith", the Jedi fought alongside the clone army, and in "The Force Awakens", Rey's lightsaber duel with Kylo Ren determined the outcome of the battle. The ordinary people's rebel army often became the auxiliary role of "responsible for blowing up the Death Star's cannon", and their role was severely weakened by the narrative of the Force.
3.2 The essence of the awakening of the common people: The "logic of survival choice" of the oppressed.
When the belief in the Force fades away, the impetus for ordinary people to rebel stems from three real-world logics:
The authenticity of pain: The tyranny of the Empire is not an abstract concept of "imbalance of the Force", but concrete suffering - the hand of the market vendor clutching sand as he died when Jedha was destroyed by the Death Star in "Rogue One"; the desperate cries of the villagers of Ferrix as their village was burned down in "Andor". These "perceptible pains" make resistance an instinctive reaction, rather than a "mission guided by the Force".
The bond of the community: The "star symbol" on the shoulder patches of the Rebel soldiers is not a symbol of the Force, but an identity marker of "we have all been hurt by the Empire". In "The Last Jedi", when the maintenance technician Rose Tico smashed the Imperial walker with a wrench after her sister's sacrifice, the essence of her action was to protect "ordinary people like her sister", rather than to "practice the Jedi doctrine".
Reconstruction of Hope: When Luke burned the Jedi texts, Leia told him, "Our hope has never been in the Jedi, but in those who choose to stand up." The hope of the Rebel Alliance was not "waiting for the next chosen one," but believing that "when everyone raises their blasters, light can be chiseled out of the darkness" - this kind of hope is rooted in the unity of ordinary people, rather than the miracles of the Force.
Image from: star wars.com
4. The subversive reconfiguration of the Star Wars IP in "Andor"
| Traditional Star Wars Narratives | Innovative Breakthroughs in Andor | Interpretation of Social Metaphors |
| Lightsaber Duel = Visual Climax | Replacing Combat with “Data Stealing” and “Prison Riots” | The Importance of Information Warfare and Unarmed Resistance in the Modern Age |
| The Force = Supernatural Powers | Rebellion = Aggregation of the Will of Ordinary People | Deconstructing the “Determinism of Talent” and Emphasizing the Power of Collective Action |
| Light vs. Darkness Dichotomy | Demonstrating Moral Gray Areas for the Resistors | The contradiction between idealism and tactical compromise in real-world politics. |
Image from: star wars.com
The courage with which Andor rips open the romantic veil of the Star Wars universe -- true defiance is never the moment a lightsaber cuts through the darkness, but the hands of ordinary people who still choose to light a match in the long dark night when they see no hope. This narrative not only does not weaken the spiritual core of Star Wars, but also gives the phrase “May the Force be with you” a heavier meaning: the Force is not in the lightsaber, but in the heart of every mortal who chooses to resist.
When the audience is accustomed to the dazzling light of the lightsaber, Andor reminds us with the narrative from the perspective of the Resistance that what is more powerful than the weapon is the courage of the mortals who know that they can't do anything about it -- this is perhaps the most profound interpretation of the word “resistance” in the Star Wars series after 47 years of its birth.
